Year: 2009
Director: Robert D. Siegel
Cast: Patton Oswalt, Kevin Corrigan, Marcia Jean Kurtz, Gino Cafarelli, Michael Rappaport
Plot outline: Paul Aufiero is a big fan of the New York Giants. A really, really big fan. When he has a violent confrontation with his favorite player, he must decide just how big a fan he is.
Standouts: I’m a fan of Patton Oswalt’s standup, but I’d never seen him do any acting before, not including one episode of King of Queens. I thought he did a good job here — it’s a tough role but he turned in a measured and thoughtful performance. I think I might have been expecting more in the way of laughs, what with Oswalt in the lead and the former editor-in-chief of The Onion as the writer-director. It was instead a rather dark character piece. It would have been easy to paint Oswalt’s character as a loser, but I thought the script had a lot of empathy for him.
![]()
Related posts:

I tried to watch this movie but couldn’t finish it. I thought the character was so pathetic I couldn’t get much sympathy for him. Probably just me and not a fault of the movie.
He is pathetic, but what I think saved me from disliking him was — what are his options? His brother, the family’s big Success Story, is a total scumbag.